As a parent, you want to do everything in your power for your children. For many parents, that means keeping them safe from the horrors of the world. One way to keep kids safe is by closing down playgrounds when there are active shooter threats. Why? Because closed-down playgrounds are safer than running outside and risking getting shot at or worse yet – being shot!
It’s been a tough 18 months for Australian families and their children. We can’t underestimate the cumulative impact of parent and career job losses, mental strain, working from home, and remote learning. As developmental pediatricians, we are increasingly concerned about how these have affected children’s development.
As a result of pandemic restrictions, children all over the world are doing significantly less physical activity and spending more time sitting. This is one reason playgrounds are so important for children right now.
Play is vital for children. It improves their learning, as well as social and physical development. Play also encourages the development of coping skills, which are critical in times of crisis.
In these uncertain and restrictive times, playing outdoors also gives kids some sense of normalcy.
Victoria closed outdoor playgrounds last week due to concerns about potential transmission. Closing playgrounds particularly impact children living in medium- and high-density housing, with limited access to outdoor play spaces. These children tend to fall into lower-income brackets and are already more vulnerable to the effects of social isolation.
While there may be some risks to keeping playgrounds open, these must be appropriately balanced with the overwhelming benefits playgrounds have for children’s development. There are certain precautions we can take to reduce the risk of COVID-19 transmission in playgrounds.
What’s the research on playgrounds and transmission?
To date, few studies have looked at the specific role of playgrounds in the transmission of SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes COVID-19. We found none that have been conducted with the Delta (B.1.617.2) variant.
Three studies focused on surface contamination — in Israel, Brazil, and Indonesia. Some samples of playground surfaces (two out of 25 in the Israeli study) tested positive. The Brazil study (which collected samples in February 2021) identified toilets, ATMs, handrails, playgrounds, and outdoor gym equipment as having the highest rates of viral contamination of all surfaces studied.
But while the virus has been found on the surfaces, there was no clear evidence of whether this has led to transmission in playgrounds. The Indonesian study suggested transmission may be more likely if children share food or drinks. However, that study only looked at journals published in 2019 and 2020, so that doesn’t account for Delta.
Two studies examined transmission in parks. A study in the United Kingdom (with data collected from June to November 2020) had two main findings. Less movement of people was associated with decreased transmission.
This supported lockdowns. But the study also noted outdoor park use was associated with decreased case rates, especially in urban areas with low green space availability (including areas of higher density living).
This is because parks offer an alternative to indoor spaces where transmission is higher. If parks close, then people congregate more indoors.
In the United States (with data collected from March to May 2020), park use increased with school closures. Interestingly, this was not associated with the growth of COVID-19 levels, either at the time or in the following weeks.
So, there is surface contamination, but no published evidence of transmission. And outdoor use of parks is not necessarily associated with more cases. And in high-density areas parks are an important space.
With the right strategies, we can minimize the risks in playgrounds while ensuring children don’t miss out on the vital need for play in a time of heightened stress and uncertainty.
We can keep playgrounds safe
Access to outdoor play is essential for healthy child development. Indoor play does not appear to equate with outdoor play in terms of benefits.
To keep playgrounds safe for children, we must ensure children are central to our thinking. Both the United Kingdom and the US offer guidelines for COVID-safe playgrounds.
These include play equipment being cleaned regularly, and children maintaining a distance of six feet (around 2 meters) from each other (clearly where possible).
Similar recommendations have been proposed in Australia:
- check current restrictions
- stay home if unwell
- socially distance
- use disinfectant wipes on equipment
- sanitize hands
- avoid using shared taps or water fountains
- remind children to avoid touching their faces
- try to prevent physical contact between children as much as possible
- avoid sharing toys
- use the playground outside peak periods
Some of these are easier to implement than others but point to the need for thinking through what we could do in playgrounds to keep them safe and open.
Anecdotally, early childhood and school teachers, particularly in low-income areas, are seeing children with less social, coping, and physical skills after 18 months of recurrent lockdowns — a significant proportion of preschool children’s whole lives.
Pediatricians are seeing families where the parents are confused and frightened to take their children to playgrounds, even when lockdown closures end. Recurrent playground closures add to these fears.
We need adults to help. They must also follow the restrictions in their state or territory. These include adhering to gathering limits, wearing face masks, and socially distancing. In the COVID-19 world, we will need to safeguard our children’s health and development.
Why we need to keep playgrounds open for kids in lockdown – and why it’s safe. For more information see Why We Need to Keep Playgrounds Open for the Kids in Lockdown – and Why It’s Safe.
If you want some practical tips, check out What You Can Do To Help Prevent the Spread of COVID-19.